44 Year Established Oyster Bay Coast Italian Restaurant- $200K SDE- As
Business Description
LEGENDARY GOLD COAST ITALIAN RESTAURANT
42 Years Established | $1.6M Revenue | $200K SDE | Asking $499K
A rare opportunity to acquire a highly profitable, deeply rooted full-service Italian restaurant in one of Long Island’s most affluent North Shore communities. Turnkey, fully staffed, and offered at approximately 2.5x Seller’s Discretionary Earnings.
THE OPPORTUNITY AT A GLANCE
Asking Price: $499,000
Annual Revenue: $1,600,000
Owner’s Cash Flow (SDE): $200,000
Location: Confidential – Nassau County Gold Coast
Years Established: 42+
Reason for Sale: Retirement
This is not a startup, turnaround, or unproven concept. This is a mature, profitable neighborhood institution built over four decades, now available as the owners prepare for retirement.
BUSINESS OVERVIEW
This family-operated Italian restaurant has been serving its community for over 42 years and has built a loyal multi-generational customer base. The business offers a proven full-service model featuring:
• Indoor and outdoor dining
• Lunch and dinner service
• Takeout and catering
• Signature retail “Sauces-To-Go” program
The menu includes traditional Italian favorites including antipasti, pasta, veal, chicken, seafood, desserts, and proprietary sauces. Recipes and sauce formulations are included in the sale.
LOCATION & MARKET STRENGTH
Situated in an affluent North Shore village on Long Island, this restaurant benefits from:
• High-income demographics
• Strong year-round residential base
• Destination dining traffic from surrounding towns
• Limited direct competition in traditional Italian dining
• Walkable village setting with strong visibility and parking
In an industry where many independent restaurants fail within five years, this operation has remained successful for over four decades in the same location—a testament to its reputation and operational strength.
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES
• 42+ years of established brand recognition
• Strong repeat customer base spanning generations
• Experienced kitchen and front-of-house staff expected to stay
• Multiple revenue streams: dine-in, catering, retail sauces
• Proprietary recipes and sauces included
• Established online reputation and word-of-mouth presence
• Healthy and consistent cash flow
GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES
A new owner can expand through:
• Scaling the retail sauce program into local specialty markets
• Growing catering with dedicated sales focus
• Expanding private parties and event bookings
• Implementing online ordering and delivery platforms
• Increasing digital marketing and social media presence
• Introducing wine dinners, special events, and loyalty programs
This is a profitable business with immediate upside—not a reinvention project.
IDEAL BUYER
Ideal for:
• Owner-operator chefs
• Experienced restaurateurs
• Hospitality groups expanding into Long Island
• Family operators seeking a legacy business
• First-time buyers seeking a stable, cash-flowing opportunity
TRANSACTION SUMMARY
Asking Price: $499,000
Revenue: $1,600,000
SDE: $200,000
Lease: Available under NDA
Included: FF&E, recipes, sauces, branding, goodwill
Training: Transition support available
42 Years Established | $1.6M Revenue | $200K SDE | Asking $499K
A rare opportunity to acquire a highly profitable, deeply rooted full-service Italian restaurant in one of Long Island’s most affluent North Shore communities. Turnkey, fully staffed, and offered at approximately 2.5x Seller’s Discretionary Earnings.
THE OPPORTUNITY AT A GLANCE
Asking Price: $499,000
Annual Revenue: $1,600,000
Owner’s Cash Flow (SDE): $200,000
Location: Confidential – Nassau County Gold Coast
Years Established: 42+
Reason for Sale: Retirement
This is not a startup, turnaround, or unproven concept. This is a mature, profitable neighborhood institution built over four decades, now available as the owners prepare for retirement.
BUSINESS OVERVIEW
This family-operated Italian restaurant has been serving its community for over 42 years and has built a loyal multi-generational customer base. The business offers a proven full-service model featuring:
• Indoor and outdoor dining
• Lunch and dinner service
• Takeout and catering
• Signature retail “Sauces-To-Go” program
The menu includes traditional Italian favorites including antipasti, pasta, veal, chicken, seafood, desserts, and proprietary sauces. Recipes and sauce formulations are included in the sale.
LOCATION & MARKET STRENGTH
Situated in an affluent North Shore village on Long Island, this restaurant benefits from:
• High-income demographics
• Strong year-round residential base
• Destination dining traffic from surrounding towns
• Limited direct competition in traditional Italian dining
• Walkable village setting with strong visibility and parking
In an industry where many independent restaurants fail within five years, this operation has remained successful for over four decades in the same location—a testament to its reputation and operational strength.
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES
• 42+ years of established brand recognition
• Strong repeat customer base spanning generations
• Experienced kitchen and front-of-house staff expected to stay
• Multiple revenue streams: dine-in, catering, retail sauces
• Proprietary recipes and sauces included
• Established online reputation and word-of-mouth presence
• Healthy and consistent cash flow
GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES
A new owner can expand through:
• Scaling the retail sauce program into local specialty markets
• Growing catering with dedicated sales focus
• Expanding private parties and event bookings
• Implementing online ordering and delivery platforms
• Increasing digital marketing and social media presence
• Introducing wine dinners, special events, and loyalty programs
This is a profitable business with immediate upside—not a reinvention project.
IDEAL BUYER
Ideal for:
• Owner-operator chefs
• Experienced restaurateurs
• Hospitality groups expanding into Long Island
• Family operators seeking a legacy business
• First-time buyers seeking a stable, cash-flowing opportunity
TRANSACTION SUMMARY
Asking Price: $499,000
Revenue: $1,600,000
SDE: $200,000
Lease: Available under NDA
Included: FF&E, recipes, sauces, branding, goodwill
Training: Transition support available
About the Business
Real Estate
- Owned or Leased
- Leased
Listing Info
- ID
- 2499459
- Listing Views
Listing ID: 2499459 The information on this listing has been provided by either the seller or a business broker representing the seller. BizQuest has no interest or stake in the sale of this business and has not verified any of the information and assumes no responsibility for its accuracy, veracity, or completeness. See our full Terms of Use. Learn how to avoid scams.
Businesses for SaleNew York Businesses for SaleNew York Food & Beverage Businesses for SaleNew York Restaurants Businesses for Sale
















