44 Year - Oyster Bay Italian Restaurant- $200K SDE- Asking $499K- Turn
Business Description
Imagine owning a piece of Long Island's Gold Coast history. This beloved Italian restaurant has been serving the same affluent North Shore community for 42 years, and now you have the rare chance to step into a turnkey operation that's already profitable and beloved by generations of families.
You'll inherit more than just a restaurant - you're getting a neighborhood institution. Picture yourself welcoming regulars who've been coming here since they were children, now bringing their own kids for Sunday dinner. The current owners have built something truly special, and they're ready to pass the torch to someone who'll appreciate what they've created.
The numbers tell a compelling story: $1.6 million in annual revenue generating $200,000 in owner cash flow. At $499,000, you're looking at just 2.5 times earnings - well below market rates for an established restaurant of this caliber. This isn't a fixer-upper or a concept you'll need to prove. It's a mature, profitable business that's been working beautifully for over four decades.
What makes this opportunity special? You'll have multiple revenue streams already in place. The dining room stays busy with lunch Monday through Friday and dinner seven days a week. There's a thriving catering operation bringing in steady income, plus a signature sauce retail program that customers love taking home. The outdoor seating extends your capacity during beautiful Long Island seasons.
Your staff situation is a dream - most of the experienced kitchen and service team plans to stay on. They know the recipes, understand the customers, and take pride in what they do. You won't be starting from scratch with hiring and training.
The location couldn't be better. You're in an established Gold Coast village where households have premium incomes and residents truly value quality dining experiences. There's limited direct competition for full-service Italian cuisine, and you'll benefit from both loyal locals and destination diners from surrounding areas.
Here's what excites us about the growth potential: the current family has run this at a comfortable pace for decades, but you could easily expand. Think about growing the catering business with dedicated marketing, placing those popular sauces in local specialty stores, or developing private party packages for this affluent market. Online ordering and delivery partnerships could add significant revenue without major investment.
The transition will be smooth. The sellers want to see their life's work continue thriving, so they're committed to training you thoroughly and helping you understand what makes this place tick. You'll get all the recipes, the sauce formulations, and insights about the customers and community that only come from four decades of experience.
Whether you're an experienced restaurateur looking for your next venture, a chef ready to own your own place, or someone seeking a stable, cash-flowing business with real community roots, this represents something increasingly rare in today's market - a genuine legacy opportunity.
The lease is secure, the equipment is well-maintained, and the reputation is golden. You're not buying potential - you're buying proven performance in one of Long Island's most desirable markets.
You'll inherit more than just a restaurant - you're getting a neighborhood institution. Picture yourself welcoming regulars who've been coming here since they were children, now bringing their own kids for Sunday dinner. The current owners have built something truly special, and they're ready to pass the torch to someone who'll appreciate what they've created.
The numbers tell a compelling story: $1.6 million in annual revenue generating $200,000 in owner cash flow. At $499,000, you're looking at just 2.5 times earnings - well below market rates for an established restaurant of this caliber. This isn't a fixer-upper or a concept you'll need to prove. It's a mature, profitable business that's been working beautifully for over four decades.
What makes this opportunity special? You'll have multiple revenue streams already in place. The dining room stays busy with lunch Monday through Friday and dinner seven days a week. There's a thriving catering operation bringing in steady income, plus a signature sauce retail program that customers love taking home. The outdoor seating extends your capacity during beautiful Long Island seasons.
Your staff situation is a dream - most of the experienced kitchen and service team plans to stay on. They know the recipes, understand the customers, and take pride in what they do. You won't be starting from scratch with hiring and training.
The location couldn't be better. You're in an established Gold Coast village where households have premium incomes and residents truly value quality dining experiences. There's limited direct competition for full-service Italian cuisine, and you'll benefit from both loyal locals and destination diners from surrounding areas.
Here's what excites us about the growth potential: the current family has run this at a comfortable pace for decades, but you could easily expand. Think about growing the catering business with dedicated marketing, placing those popular sauces in local specialty stores, or developing private party packages for this affluent market. Online ordering and delivery partnerships could add significant revenue without major investment.
The transition will be smooth. The sellers want to see their life's work continue thriving, so they're committed to training you thoroughly and helping you understand what makes this place tick. You'll get all the recipes, the sauce formulations, and insights about the customers and community that only come from four decades of experience.
Whether you're an experienced restaurateur looking for your next venture, a chef ready to own your own place, or someone seeking a stable, cash-flowing business with real community roots, this represents something increasingly rare in today's market - a genuine legacy opportunity.
The lease is secure, the equipment is well-maintained, and the reputation is golden. You're not buying potential - you're buying proven performance in one of Long Island's most desirable markets.
About the Business
Real Estate
- Owned or Leased
- Leased
- Building Sq. Ft.
- 1,400
About the Sale
- Seller Motivation
- Retiring
Listing Info
- ID
- 2500368
- Listing Views
- 7
Listing ID: 2500368 The information on this listing has been provided by either the seller or a business broker representing the seller. BizQuest has no interest or stake in the sale of this business and has not verified any of the information and assumes no responsibility for its accuracy, veracity, or completeness. See our full Terms of Use. Learn how to avoid scams.
Businesses for SaleNew York Businesses for SaleNew York Food & Beverage Businesses for SaleNew York Restaurants Businesses for Sale
















